Horrifying: Planned Parenthood official endorses infanticide

A Planned Parenthood official argued today in Florida the same argument that our president articulated when he was a Senator in Illinois – that just because a baby is born alive from a botched abortion, it doesn’t mean that child should live:

Alisa Laport Snow, the lobbyist representing the Florida Alliance of Planned Parenthood Affiliates, testified that her organization believes the decision to kill an infant who survives a failed abortion should be left up to the woman seeking an abortion and her abortion doctor.

“So, um, it is just really hard for me to even ask you this question because I’m almost in disbelief,” said Rep. Jim Boyd. “If a baby is born on a table as a result of a botched abortion, what would Planned Parenthood want to have happen to that child that is struggling for life?”

“We believe that any decision that’s made should be left up to the woman, her family, and the physician,” said Planned Parenthood lobbyist Snow.



Comment Policy: Please read our comment policy before making a comment. In short, please be respectful of others and do not engage in personal attacks. Otherwise we will revoke your comment privileges.
newest oldest most voted
wwright1961
Guest
wwright1961

I am writing this comment about infanticide because I have been following the issue of infanticide in the tiny nation of East Timor; a people who have long endured mass human rights violations and a brutal occupation by Indonesia when human life was degraded and extinguished arbitrarily by the State. Today, East Timor is free of that and is one of the most staunchly Catholic countries. Perhaps the most important tenet of Christianity is the sanctity of human life – a sanctity that was descecrated for 2 and a half decades under the Indonesian occupation resulting in the deaths of hundreds of thousands of innocent people. Which makes the present-day issue of infanticide in East Timor so perplexing. I have compiled several case histories of infanticide in East Timor over recent years and archived them on my blog, the East Timor Law and Justice Bulletin. Last week, the State Secretary… Read more »

wodiej
Guest
wodiej

All I can think of to say is disgusting.  If you haven’t seen October Baby, rent it.  It’s about this subject and very good.  It made me and my best friend cry.

PoncyJeremy
Guest
PoncyJeremy

What is wrong with liberals? If these people are so proud of their “progress” why are they so afraid to declare what it is that they stand for? Just say it. You’re advocating for the right of one human being to murder another. Why? Inconveniance. Logistics. And Conservatives are heartless?

rangerrebew
Guest
rangerrebew

Next will be geriatricide.  If a person has a heart attack and looses a pulse but is revived doesn’t mean they should live and the decision to kill them should be left up to the government, correct Ms. Snow?  People born with birth defects shouldn’t necessarily be allowed to live, correct planned parenthood?  People who don’t meet certain qualifications for an Aryan race  shouldn’t necessarily be allowed to live and could be used for experiments, right Dr. Mengele?  These are a sign of good government, correct Adolf Hitler?

NYGino
Editor
NYGino

rangerrebew Every question you asked is on exactly the same plane rangerbrew.  Thank you for an extremely well placed analogy.

LIBERTYUSA
Guest
LIBERTYUSA

…God forgive them for they know not what they are doing.”

3seven77
Guest
3seven77

LIBERTYUSA Yes they do. And for the life of me I’ll never understand it.

libertifirst
Guest
libertifirst

3seven77 LIBERTYUSA They really don’t know what they are doing, as it pertains to sin against God and mankind.

Godisright
Guest
Godisright

LIBERTYUSA and the rest of us are funding this crap through our taxes. That’s what we are doing – and WE should know that.

wodiej
Guest
wodiej

Godisright LIBERTYUSA a good reason to be unemployed.  Who would have ever thought that.

Godisright
Guest
Godisright

wodiej Godisright LIBERTYUSA  good point!

pdmd
Guest
pdmd

Responsible human beings don’t struggle with these decisions. There was a time not long ago when single women having children won government financial support.  Within decades government subsidized human breeding behavior became not as profitable as the government debt rose. Women needed government’s approval for their fertile fields to be plowed under. As government debt begins to rupture, all kinds of people on umbilical nourished dependence off government will become victims by redefinition of abortive government approved practices at both ends of the age spectrum.

The Sentinel
Guest
The Sentinel

Evil.

motherofsix
Guest
motherofsix

Hopefully these Florida lawmakers will see the true purpose of the misnamed Planned Parenthood organization.  Who could plan to be a parent when all the children are aborted who seek the assistance of their group.  It seems strange to me that a pregnant woman would wait months to seek help for an unwanted pregnancy so that the fetus is old enough and large enough to survive an abortion.   To me that would be a signal that the woman really does not want an abortion.   There are plenty of childless couples who would adopt these babies.  It is a sign of our moral decline to have laws written by the state and federal governments that seek to eliminate human life.   This is a struggle between good and evil.   The most helpless will be eliminated.   The very old will be eliminated as well when the federal healthcare law begins to decide which procedures… Read more »

libertifirst
Guest
libertifirst

Alex Jones has been warning about this for many years. He even goes further in claiming that there would be a push to kill babies up to two or three years old. As of late, he is being vindicated in that this is where the debate has gone. Many philosophical and ethics think tanks are throwing this around. This is being pushed in the white house as well. 
 http://health.gather.com/viewArticle.action?articleId=281474977775553
The simple reality is that this is no worse than killing a six week old “fetus”, as they call it. It is no worse, concerning the sin, but it is slightly worse because the people who are supposed to do no harm are becoming so inhuman that this signals the end of our society. 
If this starts happening and the church does not rebel big time, then the church will have to be considered to have lost it’s salt.

badbadlibs
Guest
badbadlibs

libertifirst Peter Singer:
“We may not want a child to start on life’s uncertain voyage if the prospects arc clouded. When this can be known at a very early stage in the voyage, we may still have a chance to make a fresh start. This means detaching ourselves from the infant who has been born, cutting ourselves free before the ties that have already begun to bind us to our child have become irresistible. Instead of going forward and putting all our effort into making the best of the situation, we can still say no, and start again from the beginning. ”
If satan had a brother ^

harryojam
Guest
harryojam

Planned parenthood has killed more minorities than the KKK, the Nazis,and all the Communist Regiimes put together. Yet they are one of Obama’s favorite organizations.

Godisright
Guest
Godisright

harryojam good point!

harryojam
Guest
harryojam

Leave it to the people that pioneered eugenics to support out right murder of children.  I think it’s time to put these murdering bastards out of business.

DawgfanInFL
Guest
DawgfanInFL

This is just plain evil.

Valin
Guest
Valin
dover
Guest
dover

They *itch about guns and the need to control them to “save the children”, but, cannot even get it into their pea brains that they” kill more children” in a week then guns are used to kill people in a decade.

ArtFaucett
Guest
ArtFaucett

Planned parenthood, should rename their org to Black Genocide.

libertifirst
Guest
libertifirst

ArtFaucett They’ll take anyone, won’t they? I know that they have focused much on blacks though.

ArtFaucett
Guest
ArtFaucett

This is why they bomb abortion clinics and kill people like Tiller. It actually saves lives in the long run.

Godisright
Guest
Godisright

I think she was wishing someone would stick a fork in her at that moment – so uncomfortable, so illogical, so ill spoken, so STUPID !!! What a demonically lead organization this is – and to garner govt. support to boot. these Planned Parenthood buildings need to be shut down, permanently.

TSA_Watcher
Guest
TSA_Watcher

Wow…I used to have a modicum of respect for Planned Parenthood. No more.

marthachandler
Guest
marthachandler

I really hate Planned Parenthood.  They have such a strong hold on our society now, that we’ll never be rid of them.

libertifirst
Guest
libertifirst

marthachandler Not until the thousand year reign.

louisiana_mom
Guest
louisiana_mom

Knowing Obamacare is just around the corner…  I wonder if this is their way of paving the way for any premie baby who requires extensive care to be euthanized?

toongoon
Guest
toongoon

louisiana_mom  
Oh! You know it mom. We have only heard the tip of the iceberg with obamacrap.
I also believe that it is in reality the replacement for the Constitution.

toongoon
Guest
toongoon

This woman should have been arrested for conspiracy to commit murder. The idea that officials were even discussing it as reasonable choice should be enough to remove them from office.

sjmom
Member
sjmom

This is murder plain and simple!

americalsgt
Guest
americalsgt

I can’t read this.  It’s too much.  I’ve been on the wrong side of this in my life and accept my failings, and acknowledge that I was wrong, but late term abortions are a bridge too far for me. I’ve posted this before on Scoop, but this article by Pat Buchanan addressing good and evil is excellent
http://www.humanevents.com/2013/03/29/is-america-still-a-good-country/

Alborn
Guest
Alborn

americalsgt I know what you mean. I sometimes wonder how I could have been so wrong about this subject but then I realized it was some more of that liberal misinformation. Abortion in not and should not be a form of birth control. No federal or state taxes should go to women’s clinics that perform abortions especially PP. This woman’s comments disgust me.

americalsgt
Guest
americalsgt

Alborn americalsgt   you’re Ok by me kiddo.

DCGere
Member
DCGere

Pure evil.

Diogenes_wy
Guest
Diogenes_wy

THOU SHALL NOT KILL!
How hard is this to understand?
The liberal left doesn’t get it and are more confused than ever: They support charging the murderer of a pregnant woman where the fetus dies with two counts of murder (California); They completely ignore the fetus who died at the Fort Hood terrorist shooting; They keep saying abortion is a woman’s choice when the real choice is to engage in sex (the baby is a consequence of that decision and to terminate its life because of regrets over that choice is murder).

We’ve exceeded 50 million dead through abortion (that’s five times more than the Nazis killed in the holocaust).
  Sodom and Gomorrah were destroyed because God was upset by the cries of the innocent (children).  Anybody notice the increase in asteroid near miss activity lately? God does have a rather draconian way of sorting things out.

louisiana_mom
Guest
louisiana_mom

What’s next? Claiming it is okay to murder, er “abort” a baby up to 6 weeks old? When do these psychopaths recognize a human life in that mass of tissues? When it’s old enough to talk and feed itself? God have mercy on all of us…

pajamakat
Guest
pajamakat

louisiana_mom This is just the beginning. Wait until they don’t want the elderly around any longer.

deTocqueville1
Guest
deTocqueville1

pajamakat louisiana_mom Exactly, and then those considered less than their ‘ideal’.

toongoon
Guest
toongoon

louisiana_mom  
All that was missing was the little square mustache under her nose.

WinMissouri
Guest
WinMissouri

This should go viral. She and PP are pathetic. Are you kidding, because a hospital may or may not be 45 minutes away, a child should die. Oh Jesus help us educate Americans about the slaughtering of the children.

ryanomaniac
Member
ryanomaniac

They need to be taken behind the shed and two bullets behind the ear. If I could get away with it I’d do it myself. These people are animals and have no right to live on earth.

57thunderbird
Guest
57thunderbird

ryanomaniac Amen to that!

Godisright
Guest
Godisright

ryanomaniac Right on. The people who have no respect for life need not live it themselves. Why would they put themselves through any more trouble than what they have been through already?

tavadesigns
Guest
tavadesigns

This is just shocking, when did our society fall this far from morality and how can anyone allow a  baby to die this way, this is beyond humanness

badbadlibs
Guest
badbadlibs

tavadesigns When? When God was removed from all vestiges of society.

Laurel
Member
Laurel

Abomination Obamnation.

celestiallady
Member
celestiallady

It’s murder – plain and simple!  What is wrong with these people? They are awful examples of human beings.

57thunderbird
Guest
57thunderbird

celestiallady I think it would be easier to answer what is right with these people.Simple answer,Nothing.

cabensg
Guest
cabensg

Heartless fiends.  The sociopath we now have as president voted for it twice.

57thunderbird
Guest
57thunderbird

cabensg Dear leader voted in favor of this practice when he was an Illinois senator.

57thunderbird
Guest
57thunderbird

Murderous malcontents!

pushtheredbutton
Guest
pushtheredbutton

This woman is the reason I praise God for hell everyday.

StevenValdez
Guest
StevenValdez

Abortion is the real abomination. Destroying a life that God created. The murders is tolerated and innocent is killed. Damn is there at any point in that mother’s, doctors, or these idiots at PP think and say “hey this baby is meant to be here for a reason, maybe we shouldn’t do this”

pushtheredbutton
Guest
pushtheredbutton

StevenValdez How can it be an abomination? After all, its legal, right Valdo?

StevenValdez
Guest
StevenValdez

pushtheredbutton You don’t get it. Destroying a life is a lot different.

pushtheredbutton
Guest
pushtheredbutton

StevenValdez pushtheredbutton Hey. Don’t blame me. Only using your logic from earlier.  
The law is supreme. Right, Valdo?

StevenValdez
Guest
StevenValdez

pushtheredbutton law is supreme even in cases you don’t agree with in this country. I do not support murder of the innocent life. To me abortion is an abomination legal or not. There should be a way to stop it due to the killing of life, which government should be protecting. Two consenting adults and what they do in their life is not a big deal to me, they aren’t criminals until they commit a crime just like everyone else. There is a difference. Abortion should be a murderous criminal act and it isn’t.

Isaiah 54
Guest
Isaiah 54

This is an evil plague, a genocide, an evil that has dehumanized our nation.

Isaiah 54
Guest
Isaiah 54

These are Obama’s and Hillary’s (and Bill Gates’s) people.

stage9
Guest
stage9

I just got through posting this on FB. 
THIS ABSOLUTELY BLEW MY MIND!
What I find fascinating about liberals is how they’ve started to deflect and avoid answering questions, which they should already have the answers to, but do so to avoid the implications of self-incrimination.  
Here is a representative of PP whose role it is to articulate to the public the practices and procedures of PP, yet she continues to either deflect or play dumb. 
When they’re boxed into a corner liberals always tend to play dumb, leaving you to wonder, are they lying or just downright incompetent? If she’s lying, then she’s perjuring herself. If she’s incompetent, then why does she hold the position of spokesperson for her organization?

deTocqueville1
Guest
deTocqueville1

This is blatant but hardly surprising. We have known this was coming for a long time. Women can commit murder of both their unborn and birthed babies.  We will have death panels with Obamacare and we will no doubt with this evil President  have expansion of murder elsewhere for those who are ‘unfit’ or ‘inferior’. Josef Mengale must be laughing in Hell.

K-Bob
Editor
K-Bob

The distance from Planned Parenthood lobbyist Snow’s position, and The Gulags is a journey of only one step.

TIMERUNNERSC
Guest
TIMERUNNERSC

just a slight correction my friend, they are a 1/2 step journey, they wear boots.

Back to Top of Comments