Trump defends his 2017 Charlottesville comments against media LIES and he’s not wrong…

For some reason Trump was asked about his 2017 Charlottesville comments this morning and he once again defended his comments.

Watch:

In case you didn’t hear the question clearly, Trump was asked if he still says there were very fine people on both sides in Charlottesville.



This is actually really important because the media continues to lie about what he actually said, accusing him of praising the Neo-Nazis and white supremacists.

As pointed out by Steve Cortes at Real Clear Politics the other day, here’s the transcript of Trump’s comments from 2017:

“Excuse me, they didn’t put themselves down as neo-Nazis, and you had some very bad people in that group. But you also had people that were very fine people on both sides. You had people in that group – excuse me, excuse me, I saw the same pictures you did. You had people in that group that were there to protest the taking down of, to them, a very, very important statue and the renaming of a park from Robert E. Lee to another name.”

They point out that he went on to reiterate that he wasn’t talking about the Neo-Nazis:

“I’m not talking about the neo-Nazis and white nationalists because they should be condemned totally.”

Cortes concludes…

As a man charged with publicly explaining Donald Trump’s often meandering and colloquial vernacular in highly adversarial TV settings, I appreciate more than most the sometimes-murky nature of his off-script commentaries. But these Charlottesville statements leave little room for interpretation. For any honest person, therefore, to conclude that the president somehow praised the very people he actually derided, reveals a blatant and blinding level of bias.

The problem is the media conflates the legitimate protesters with the White Nationalists and Neo-Nazis, and clearly Trump was not doing that. But the media continues to spread lies about what Trump actually said.

(h/t: Tracy)

Comment Policy: Please read our comment policy before making a comment. In short, please be respectful of others and do not engage in personal attacks. Otherwise we will revoke your comment privileges.

59
Leave a Reply

Please Login to comment
17 Comment threads
42 Thread replies
18 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
newest oldest most voted
Rutgers
Member
Active Member
Rutgers

It’s pretty clear what he meant since there were roughly 4 distinct groups that showed up to Charlottesville. One group was there to protest taking the Lee statue down and renaming the park, another group was there to protest TOO take the statue down and to rename the park. OK, those groups are the “good” people who didn’t show up to fight but to exercise their right to assemble and protest. The 3rd group is the neo-nazis and their allies, they showed up to cause trouble, same with group 4 which was ANTIFA/BLM and others who showed up to fight – they brought masks, shields and bats with them after all. The last two groups are the groups that were called out as “bad” by Trump. And yes the event was organized originally by neo-nazis however that does not mean only those people and their opponents showed up – press… Read more »

ozzy
Member
Active Member
ozzy

A few neo-Nazi’s on one side and a few Communist on the other yet nobody mentions the commies. What Stalin and Mau did was significantly worse.

DinoDoc
Member
Active Member
DinoDoc

Are we seriously relitigating the question of a Neo Nazi rally containing normal people? Is that what defense of Trump has brought us too?

Tracy
Member
Noble Member
Tracy

Yes he has brought us to telling the truth. How dare he.

“I’m not talking about the neo-Nazis and white nationalists because they should be condemned totally.”

DinoDoc
Member
Active Member
DinoDoc

Here’s a pic of the flyer for the event.

What about that screams it’d be a non-Neo Nazi rally? Let’s not forget the widely covered “Jews will not replace us!” march through UVA.

Tracy
Member
Noble Member
Tracy

That was one group, there were others as well.

DinoDoc
Member
Active Member
DinoDoc

Evidence.

Tracy
Member
Noble Member
Tracy

I remember the lead up to Charlottesville, and what was discussed. All of it overshadowed now by the riot.

Tracy
Member
Noble Member
Tracy

I cant find what I was remembering from before, but he did come out and condemn the nazis there is no doubt.

DinoDoc
Member
Active Member
DinoDoc

Saying Trump was wrong about one thing doesn’t make you a Democrat.

Abe Lincoln
Member
Noble Member
Abe Lincoln

The Charlottesville event was more complicated than the media wants to portray., but if you bought the crap the media was serving, you would think that Charlottesville was only about white nationalists and violence they perpetrated against peaceful leftists. In fact, the BLM and Antifa protestors were also just as violent. And in addition to those violent groups, there were others who were there to express support for/against removing Robert E Lee statue without any violence. And these are the groups Trump was talking about “fine people”.

C.W. Smith
Member
Active Member
C.W. Smith

Abe LincolnAbe Lincoln

In fact, the BLM and Antifa protestors were also just as violent.

That’s true, but they didn’t kill anybody (that time).

Abe Lincoln
Member
Noble Member
Abe Lincoln

Antifa’s violence is horrendous–they may not have killed anyone, but they hurt a lot of people then and previously.

C.W. Smith
Member
Active Member
C.W. Smith

Abe LincolnAbe Lincoln I’m well aware of that. But the fact remains that the only people who got murdered at that event were the ones that alt-right jackass ran over with his car.

ElvisWasAHero2Most
Member
ElvisWasAHero2Most

Trump defends his 2017 Charlottesville comments against media LIES and he’s not wrong… Does anyone else feel this headline is ambiguous? Trump defended himself and he was not wrong? Why not just say he was right? Saying “not wrong” seems like something Kellyanne Conway would say to appease Trump. Turning to Trump’s double-downing of the “fine people” comment. Conservatives have turned toward defending Trump on this, that Trump was discussing the people who wanted the statues to stay or whatever, but also that Trump specifically condemned the neo-nazis. However the fact remains, the rally in Charlottesville was always billed as an alt-right event. It was organized by white nationalist Jason Kessler. David Duke and another famous white nationalist, Richard Spencer, were scheduled speakers. The group of men wielding tiki torches and chanting “Jews will not replace us” the night before the main event set a pretty clear tone. So Trump… Read more »

Tracy
Member
Noble Member
Tracy

What color is the sky in your world?

What possible reason would Trump have to pander to white nationalists? Yes they were prominent at the rally because that is the ONLY thing the MSM focused on, but Trump also knew there was a rally to protect the monument.

No one else’s fault that yall weren’t aware of different groups there that were not Unite the Right or Antifa.

ElvisWasAHero2Most
Member
ElvisWasAHero2Most

How was the rally advertised? It was advertised as the “Unite The Right Rally” and as I previously said, organized by white nationalist Jason Kessler. So for Trump to say there were good people on the side of folks who are White Nationalists chanting they won’t be replaced by Jews is…. disheartening at best from an American president in these times.

Tracy
Member
Noble Member
Tracy

@elvis Do you even read what you are responding to?

ElvisWasAHero2Most
Member
ElvisWasAHero2Most

Yes [White supremacists] were prominent at the rally because that is the ONLY thing the MSM focused on, but Trump also knew there was a rally to protect the monument.

They were prominent because the rally was organized by, wait for it…. White supremacists. It’s the same reason you heard the hate-stirring chants that occurred at the rally. I am glad the media pointed out who organized such an event.

Surely there’s “good people” at any event, heck there’s even some “good people” in ISIS…. but for a country with as frightening a record on race as ours, your hope is the leader of the free world would be aware and not protect racists simply because they voted for him. The point Biden makes, to me at least, is we have a sloppy president who panders to the Stephen Millers of our country and that ain’t America.

Tracy
Member
Noble Member
Tracy

Elvis,
Who was Trump referring to as good people when in the next sentance he said he wasnt talking about neo nazi supremacists.

He knew who was there.

trytothink
Member
Noble Member
trytothink

“Trump defended himself and he was not wrong? Why not just say he was right?” Because these guys write headlines all day and try to punch them up to be colloquial and click-worthy. “He’s Not Wrong” is common enough so that we all know what it means and it’s meant to sound a little sassy. “the rally in Charlottesville was always billed as an alt-right event” Billed by whom? By the very media that tried to smear Trump by ignoring the context of his statement? Your reasoning there is circular and thus flawed. The statue teardowns were in the news at the time and people who aren’t racists were upset at the biased attack on history. Is such an event also a place where white nationalists would want to appear? Of course. It was also a place where Antifa appeared, but I don’t see you saying it was billed as… Read more »

ElvisWasAHero2Most
Member
ElvisWasAHero2Most

Because these guys write headlines all day and try to punch them up to be colloquial and click-worthy.

Sigh…. true. I always fear folks will take the headlines seriously.

Billed by whom? By the very media that tried to smear Trump by ignoring the context of his statement?

The rally was organized by Richard Spencer…. I mean, if you want to say it’s not an alt-right event, then…. you’re in a bubble.

Is such an event also a place where white nationalists would want to appear? Of course. It was also a place where Antifa appeared, but I don’t see you saying it was billed as “an Antifa event”.

Right, this was an alt-right event so Antifa showed up in protest of their protest…. so it was not an Antifa event.

Agesilaos
Member
Active Member
Agesilaos

“Trump defended himself and he was not wrong?” Why not just say he was right?

Um, litotes?

Central Valley
Member
Trusted Member
Central Valley

You know what shakes the nation’s conscience Joe ? Infaticide!

Joe Biden didn’t say a damn thing, still doesn’t, about INFATICIDE!

Enough with the Charlottesville garbage. Trump has been the greatest president for black Americans. Black middle class is growing. Under Joe and Barack, blacks only received constant race baiting and food stamps.

Joe’s going back to “they’re going to put you back into chains ⛓” garbage to run on. Dispicable.

President Trump needs to hammer infanticide every single day until he’s re-elected. When the media spews their typical race busting garbage, throw infanticide back at them.

Do the suburbs support infaticide Joe? Do women support infaticide? I highly doubt it. Landslide.

AT
Member
Noble Member
AT

I liked WW2. There were very fine people on both sides. Americans, Nazis – fine, fine people.

WHAT!?

Uh…. *thinks fast* uhhhh….. I’m talking about that Schindler dude. You know, from the movie.

Then why the hell didn’t you just say THAT!?

Come on Donald. Don’t piss down my back and tell me it’s raining.

Tracy
Member
Noble Member
Tracy

True! Except the part where he said Nazis were fine people.

Chow Yun Fatty
Member
Trusted Member
Chow Yun Fatty

A number of nazi soldiers worked to assasinate Hitler, but only maimed him. They were executed for that.

A number of Italians rose up against Mussolini and beat him to death.

A number of Japanese opposed the war but out of a sense of bushido code, continued to fight.

It’s impossible to know every individual soldiers motivation. As a whole, yes, Italians, Germans, and Japanese were the enemy and considered evil. But I’m sure there were individual soldiers who disagreed with their leadership. So yes, I’d feel safe that even in WW2 there were fine people on both sides.

SisterMary
Member
Active Member
SisterMary

Are we talking about the same media that still quotes Sarah Palin incorrectly?
Leopards don’t change their spots…

sjmom
Member
Noble Member
sjmom

We know what the truth of Charlottesville is and the MSM lied. The MSM is going to have a lot to do to CYA for Biden. He’s got enough baggage it’s going to take a freight train to carry it all.

Kenoshamarge
Member
Noble Member
Kenoshamarge

And being Biden he will add things to the luggage on a daily basis. He may have a brain but most of the time it isn’t connected to his mouth.

hubman
Member
Trusted Member
hubman

For some reason Trump was asked about his 2017 Charlottesville comments this morning

Probably because Joe Biden made it the centerpiece of his announcement that he was running for president. Apparently, he wanted to actually travel to Charlottesville to make the announcement, but a number of the residents complained about the idea. So he played a video about Charlottesville, and repeated the smear about “fine people on both sides,” and offered it as the reason he was jumping into the race.

sjmom
Member
Noble Member
sjmom

hubmanhubman Biden has enough of his own problems. Trump, if he wants, will have a field day. I hope he brings up Hunter’s business dealings in the Ukraine and how Biden got the prosecutor fired because he didn’t want Hunter investigated.

hubman
Member
Trusted Member
hubman

sjmomsjmom I’m kinda hoping Biden somehow miraculously gets the nomination, just to see it all fall apart again. But I doubt he’ll get that far.

He’s not as crazy as most of the Democratic field this time around, but he doesn’t have enough pull to resist the crazy. He only survives if he joins them during the primary season, then betrays them in the general. I doubt he can pull it off.

Agesilaos
Member
Active Member
Agesilaos

Unfortunately, I’ve heard Ben Shapiro repeat this version of events on his show some time ago.

Ciceroni Excogitatoris
Member
Noble Member
Ciceroni Excogitatoris

Yes, I heard him as well, Age. Shapiro’s TDS tends to surface every now and then… it’s sad.

He did the same thing with the Covington kid…

Tracy
Member
Noble Member
Tracy

Little Ben disappoints often.

Kenoshamarge
Member
Noble Member
Kenoshamarge

The media is able to get away with their lies for several reasons:

1. The abysmal ignorance of many on the left.
2. The haters believe what they want to be true.
3. The right allows such crap without fighting back. Trump fights back and I doubt they will ever forgive him for showing them up for the cowards they have been and still remain.

Media is broken beyond repair and doesn’t inform the public.

Dr. Strangelove
Member
Noble Member
Dr. Strangelove

I’m afraid that there is much abysmal ignorance in the middle, also.

Kenoshamarge
Member
Noble Member
Kenoshamarge

Thanks to decades of the gift of a “liberal” education abysmal ignorance is a national catastrophe.

C.W. Smith
Member
Active Member
C.W. Smith

Dr. StrangeloveDr. Strangelove I’m afraid that at this point, ignorance has become a bipartisan epidemic.

Dr. Strangelove
Member
Noble Member
Dr. Strangelove

Can’t argue with that.

Tracy
Member
Noble Member
Tracy

You know there are some things Trump has said that were not laudable, why go all in on a lie?

Dr. Strangelove
Member
Noble Member
Dr. Strangelove

It’s a really, really great lie.

Dr. Strangelove
Member
Noble Member
Dr. Strangelove

Plugs conveniently left out the important part. But would we expect anything different? Ben Shapiro also missed it, which surprised me a bit

Agesilaos
Member
Active Member
Agesilaos

Shapiro has repeated this a few times on his show.

Dr. Strangelove
Member
Noble Member
Dr. Strangelove

You’d think that a lawyer would be more thorough.

Ciceroni Excogitatoris
Member
Noble Member
Ciceroni Excogitatoris

Shapiro is a lawyer with bouts of TDS…

Watchman
Member
Noble Member
Watchman

I like Ben, but he does miss it sometimes.

Dr. Strangelove
Member
Noble Member
Dr. Strangelove

I think that he may have a dislike for Tromp which taints his objectivity.

Kenoshamarge
Member
Noble Member
Kenoshamarge

@Dr. Strangelove – surprised me too. Ben’s usually better than that.

Tracy
Member
Noble Member
Tracy

They did the same thing with his comments on immigrants being animals. That is not what he said yet the lie persists.

Sentinel
Member
Noble Member
Sentinel

I appreciate the clarification and then verification from Steve Cortes. He’s right. We were all right. The damned, criminal MSM was all wrong. And continues to be. So if they were honest (they’re not), they’d wear this like a badge: That they consistently misquote an often tongue-tied POTUS in order to twist, spin or malign what he actually said (or meant) with something that fits their destructive agenda. I continue to view the vast majority of the MSM as an enemy of America. I do!

PVG
Member
Noble Member
PVG

Levin tackled this yesterday as Biden released a campaign video where he completely lied about what Trump said regarding Charlottesville. Typical!
Biden, the next HRC!

Ciceroni Excogitatoris
Member
Noble Member
Ciceroni Excogitatoris

I hope Joe Biden is asked on The View, why he is continuing to spread the lie… I won’t hold my breath!

Kenoshamarge
Member
Noble Member
Kenoshamarge

Please don’t @Ciceroni Excogitatoris – we’d miss you.

Dr. Strangelove
Member
Noble Member
Dr. Strangelove

He’d have to bring plenty of Chapstick for his heinie.

Kenoshamarge
Member
Noble Member
Kenoshamarge

Right out of the box Biden is in deep trouble. Anita Hill ain’t buying his “apology” – Obama didn’t endorse him and the other old white goat is stealing much of his thunder. Biden will have to move further and further left and when he does Bernie will all ready be there.

https://assets.amuniversal.com/51e33a004a140137964f005056a9545d.jpg

Dr. Strangelove
Member
Noble Member
Dr. Strangelove

I foresee lots of video showing what a “hands on” politician he is.

Kenoshamarge
Member
Noble Member
Kenoshamarge
Back to Top of Comments